Integrity · Experience · Accuracy
Call 480-443-9064

Digital & Computer Forensics

Computer, Mobile & Digital Forensics News

Calender Aug 5, 2015 at 09:33am

Tom Brady – Fair or Not Fair?



deflated football
The NFL did not reverse the 4-game suspension associated with accusations surrounding Tom Brady and his potential involvement with deflating of footballs during last season's playoff games. Once announced Brady posted a response on his Facebook page indicating he "replaced his broken Samsung phone with a new iPhone 6 after my attorneys made it clear to the NFL that my actual phone device would not be subjected to investigation under any circumstances." He goes on to state "we turned over detailed pages (paper) of cell phone records and all of the email records and all of the email that Mr. Wells requested" (Hillary revisited).

There was too much on the line to even think about not turning over, or even worse, destroying the phone. If there was nothing on the phone he could have simply handed it over and the truth would have been told. He could have also gone to a computer forensic expert to image whatever could be imaged from the phone (just in case). If the chip was not damaged, there is a strong likelihood of full recovery. It is likely that if there was a qualified forensic expert involved, and all efforts were undertaken to recover the data, it would have placed some weight on the NFL's decision and some relief may have resulted. He failed to subject the phone to investigation, did not take proper care of it and it was ruled he had to paid a price.

In comparison, the Boston Marathon Bomber's friend was sentenced to 2½ years for deleting his browser history when he felt the heat of an ensuing investigation.

If the investigation moves further, a check can take place to see if syncing was done with any computers or vehicles he owns. Cloud based backups can also be looked for. His social media accounts can also be checked. When I took a brief glance at his posts, there did not appear to be any emotions or feelings held back.
Craig Reinmuth

About The Author

Craig Reinmuth is a Certified Public Accountant with over 35 years of experience. He is President of Expert Insights, P.C., a full service litigation support firm providing services to legal communities nationwide. He has testified as an expert witness in Federal District Courts as well as District and Superior Courts in the States of Arizona, California, Montana, Nevada and Wisconsin. Learn more about Craig.

Subscribe to Our Blog

Request A consultation

Let Expert Insights alleviate some of the stress of case preparation and presentation. To speak with a litigation expert about your case, call 480-443-9064 or email us using the form below.
© 2015 - 2019 Expert Insights P.C. All rights reserved.
Tap Here To Call Us! 480-443-9064